Client: Rutherford Gifts, Wellingborough
Industry: E-commerce / Gifts & Retail
Challenge: Low margins in a saturated online gift market
Solution: Strategic repositioning through product personalisation
Results: Increased margins, booming sales, business expansion to three laser machines and a ten-person team

Background

Rutherford Gifts, based in Wellingborough, was operating in the highly competitive online gift market. While their product range was attractive and well-presented, they faced a significant challenge common to many in their sector: commoditisation. With numerous competitors offering identical or similar products, price became the only differentiator, leading to tight margins and limited growth potential.

The Challenge

Despite a functional e-commerce platform and consistent traffic, Rutherford Gifts was struggling to generate healthy profit margins. Their products, while well-made, were widely available from other online retailers, leaving little room for price flexibility. Returns and refunds also impacted profitability, especially around key gifting seasons.

Our Approach

We were brought in to assess the business and create a tailored marketing plan with a focus on long-term profitability and brand differentiation. Our discovery process included a review of:

• Customer feedback
  
  
• Competitor positioning
  
  
• Sales and return data
  
  
• Operational capacity and fulfilment
  
  

Key Insight: The Power of Personalisation

A pivotal insight emerged early: personalisation adds emotional and monetary value. When a gift is tailored specifically to the recipient — with names, dates, messages, or unique engravings — it becomes significantly more meaningful and less likely to be returned.

Additionally, personalised items naturally command a higher price point, boosting profit margins without significantly increasing production costs.

Strategic Implementation

1. Business Model Shift
   Rutherford Gifts pivoted from a commodity-based product strategy to a value-based, personalised gift offering.
   
   
2. Investment in Technology
   A laser engraving machine was purchased to enable in-house customisation of a wide range of products, from wooden keepsakes to glassware and metal items.
   
   
3. Website Optimisation
   The e-commerce platform was updated to allow customers to:
   
   
   
   • Easily enter personalisation details
     
     
   • Preview their custom text
     
     
   • Understand the added value of unique, bespoke gifts
     
     
4. Marketing Messaging
   All marketing materials — from social media to email campaigns — were rewritten to emphasise the emotional value and exclusivity of personalised gifts.
   
   

The Results

The transformation was swift and impressive:

• Margins Increased Substantially: Personalised products commanded significantly higher prices, without drastically increasing costs.
  
  
• Returns and Refunds Dropped: Customers were far less likely to return bespoke items.
  
  
• Sales Boomed: The personalisation strategy resonated with both new and returning customers, particularly around peak gifting seasons.
  
  
• Scalability: The initial success led to the purchase of two additional laser engraving machines.
  
  
• Job Creation: Rutherford Gifts expanded their team and now employs ten full-time staff to support production, fulfilment, and customer service.
  
  

Conclusion

The case of Rutherford Gifts illustrates the power of strategic differentiation in a commoditised market. By identifying and leveraging personalisation as both a value-add and margin-booster, the business evolved from a struggling online retailer to a thriving, scalable brand with a unique market position.

‍